The world collectively gasped on the morning of December 16, 2009, which was the day Reese Witherspoon and Jake Gyllenhaal officially verified their rumored split. The lovebirds of three years who met on the set of the political thriller Rendition were seemingly two peas into a pod until Jakey grew tired of Reese’s demanding family life and nonstop work schedule – or so the story goes.

Both parties eventually moved on; Jake currently has his hands full with musician Taylor Swift, and Reese is happily tied up in a relationship with agent Jim Toth, which appears to be going quite well.

Read Reese Witherspoon Reveals Her First Date Pet Peeve

However, just on the off chance that the bubbly Oscar-winner hasn’t found Mr. Right, We have carefully selected a few eligible men who we believe would be the perfect match for our down-home Southern gal. Read on and see if you agree, and make sure to see Reese in How Do You Know, hitting theaters December 17!

Next: Matthew Morrison