French women have always been admired for their fashion savvy, but on February 21, it was a tiny American in Paris who made headlines for her bold new look. Three-year-old Shiloh Jolie-Pitt debuted a sporty cropped ’do as she shopped for clothes at a Bonpoint on the Rue de l'Université in the Left Bank with her dad, Brad Pitt, and big sis, Zahara.

While Shiloh certainly looked adorable with her chopped locks, her cut has been somewhat controversial. Many bloggers mistook the towheaded tot for her 19-month-old brother, Knox, when Brad, 46, and partner Angelina Jolie took her boating in Venice on February 18, and critics have complained that the ’do is a don’t for a little girl.

Read Will Madonna’s Mini-Me, Lourdes, Be a Bigger Star Than Her Mom?

Still, Shiloh has proudly been a tomboy from the very start. In June 2006, the infant wore a blue Kingsley Pots & Pans tee for her very first cover shoot with People magazine. More recently she’s been spotted sporting camouflage pants, ties, fedoras, and an array of outfits in gray and black. According to Jolie-Pitt insiders, it’s Shiloh — not her famous parents — who determines which duds she’ll wear. A Bonpoint eyewitness tells People magazine that while 5-year-old Zahara opted for girlie pieces, “Shiloh only wanted items from the boys' collection.”

That certainly comes as no surprise to Papa Pitt. “She only wants to be called John. John or Peter,” he told Oprah Winfrey last year. “So it's a Peter Pan thing."

Read Why Can’t Suri Cruise Play Dress Up?

While several celebrity websites have slammed Shiloh for emulating the wardrobe worn by her dad and her big brothers Maddox, 8, and Pax, 6, the truth is that she may simply be following in her gorgeous mom’s footsteps. “I wanted to be Indiana Jones when I was growing up,” Angie, 34, admits. “I was a real tomboy.”

And look at how nicely she turned out!