Have you ever been accused of having a ‘fossil fetish’? You know, where you have the hots for a guy that’s way older than you?

It’s OK, you’re not alone. In fact, plenty of females find men with thinning or gray hair and AARP membership cards extremely lust-worthy. Or, maybe we should say drool-worthy, considering the fact that some of these guys may very well soon be drooling somewhere in a retirement home.

We asked readers to confess which aging celebrities they still find incredibly sexy, despite their advancing years. The biggest surprise? George Clooney wasn’t among the top vote-getters! Here, in no particular order, are the top eight picks:

Robert Downey Jr., 44
Despite his ugly drug-addicted past, women can’t get enough of the now clean, ripped, and talented Iron Man star, even if he is over 40. “His sarcasm and sense of humor make him so attractive to me,” says Deidre, 22.  

Lisa, 23, agrees. “He always carries himself well and has a very dry sense of humor, which is my favorite part. Also, did you see him at the Oscars? His outfit was fabulous, especially the sneakers and bow-tie.”

Read 10 Things You Didn’t Know About Robert Downey Jr. 

Daniel Craig, 42
Even though he’s the youngest of the bunch, this generation’s James Bond may not have much longer before he has to turn in his double agent badge, and that doesn’t bother the women we heard from. “Between his British accent, gravelly voice and the muscles he sports as James Bond, it's hard to pick just one reason why he's hot,” says Lindsay, 30.

“I love his accent,” admits Tiffani, 32. “He has that rugged look in his face and that body is sexy, sexy, sexy.”

Anthony Bourdain, 53
The gray-haired No Reservations host has women half his age lusting after him as much as his food. “I know he’s married with a child,” says Kaitlin, 23, “but a man who knows his way around food and who is able to relate so well to so many people around the world is amazing. I would totally dump my boyfriend for him.”

“He’s on my ‘freebie list,’” confesses Annemarie, 26. “He’s smoking hot and very sexy!”

Brad Pitt, 46
This list wouldn’t be complete without the one and only Brad Pitt on it. Even though he’s been sporting that funky gray beard and is father to a clan of children, there’s still something special about this guy that will always make women swoon. “Isn't he pretty much perfection incarnate?” asks Ashley, 25. “He could do anything to me whenever, wherever. My boyfriend and I have an understanding, just in case Mr. Pitt ever comes to our town.”